Thursday, November 17, 2011

Pretty Little Liars: Critical Thinking Question #2

this book shows what girls go through in middle and high school to fit it, and peer pressure. in the book Spencer, Aria, Emily, and Hanna are all pressured to do things they don't want to by Alison, just so they can fit in. they don't know how to say no to Alison, they worship her. but at the same time they hate her. i think that in this text Alison's point of view is missing. all the others girls point of view is included except hers, she talks in the book and does things. but we don't really get to see the world through her eyes. 

the effect that this has is that we see Alison as kind of a "bully" and a stubborn brat. the girls are always saying how she is flirting with her sisters boyfriend and she wants everything perfect and her way. since Alison's voice is excluded we don't get to know why she really acts this way. maybe she has low self-esteem and just wants to cover it up. maybe she hasn't ever had a real friend so she thinks that this is the way to treat them, to make sure that they never have the courage to leave her.

since Alison's perspective is excluded all the other girls stand out more. so we focus in on them and what they are saying , and since they are all saying negative  and mean things about Alison. it leads us into thinking that they are right and that she really is this person.

i think that if Alison's point of view was present then the girls would be overshadowed because we would get to know who the true Alison is, then we wouldn't care what the other girls would have to say. we wouldn't have to rely  on their words to try and see what kind of person Alison was. i think that the reason the author did this was to keep the reader guessing throughout the whole book, so they would just want to keep reading. is the author put in Alison's perspective then it would be boring because we have nothing to infer, since we know everything already.

1 comment:

  1. Hey Hanaa <3<3<3<3<3 I really liked your post! I'm reading the same book- as you know :)- and I agree with almost everything you mentioned in your response, other than the part where you said you think the reader doesn't pay attention to Alison because her perspective is missing. I personally thought the opposite. I felt that the reader would pay more attention to her, being that she's the only main character missing a POV, so I agreed with the part about us having to figure out Alison, but I just think that actually makes us pay even more attention to her. Great job with the post, though! :D <3 xoxo

    ReplyDelete